1. For selective breeding to be effective, there must be genetic variation present in the population, a way of identifying individuals for selection that are likely to transmit the desired properties to the descendants, and sufficient spare reproductive capacity so that the population can be bred from only the chosen.
2. Selective breeding can raise ethical concerns because it involves manipulating animals for human purposes, which can be seen as a violation of animal rights. Some ethical considerations include:
* Animal welfare: Selective breeding can involve surgical procedures and the sacrifice of some animals.
* Animal dignity: Animals should be treated with respect for their dignity.
* Proportionality: The suffering and benefits of the animals should be considered and balanced.
* Reducing the number of animals: The number of animals used should be reduced when possible.
* Breed preservation: The breed should stay true to its origins.
* Health and wellbeing: The health and wellbeing of the parents and their offspring should be prioritized.
3. Selective breeding, also known as artificial selection, has contributed to the development of new plant and animal varieties by:
* Improving efficiency
Selective breeding has increased the efficiency of plants and animals, such as by increasing milk yield from cows and corn yields in the United States.
* Developing new traits
Selective breeding has resulted in new traits in plants and animals, such as sweeter fruits, plumper chickens, and fluffier puppies.
* Creating new varieties
Selective breeding has created new varieties of plants and animals, such as domesticated animals known as breeds and domesticated plants known as varieties.
* Developing ornamental plants
Selective breeding has created ornamental plants with particular colors or shapes.
4. Selective breeding can have several risks and drawbacks, including:
* Reduced genetic diversity
Selective breeding can reduce the genetic variation in a population, making them more susceptible to disease and attack by insects. This can be irreversible, and can lead to populations lacking the genetic alternatives to adapt to new events.
* Physical problems
Selective breeding can lead to physical problems in animals and plants. For example, dogs that are selectively bred to be very small may have more frequent kneecap dislocations. Large dogs may have hip problems, while breeds with long necks and large heads may have spinal cord compression.
* Inbreeding
Selective breeding often involves inbreeding, which is when closely related individuals are bred together. Inbred populations are more likely to inherit two copies of recessive gene variants, which can lead to genetic conditions.
* New traits
Selective breeding can create new traits that were not present in the original population, and can cause pain or death.
* Food source disruption
Selective breeding can disrupt food sources for organisms in the wild. For example, animals that naturally fed on a certain plant may not be able to feed on it after selective breeding.
* Breeding for specific traits
Depending on the traits chosen, selective breeding may not always lead to higher productivity rates. For example, hens that are selectively bred to lay eggs may not meet industry standards for meat.
5. Key points about selective breeding and biodiversity:
* Reduced genetic diversity:
By choosing only certain individuals to breed, the genetic diversity within a population decreases, as less variation is passed on to future generations.
* Inbreeding concerns:
Selective breeding often involves breeding closely related individuals, increasing the risk of inbreeding which can lead to harmful genetic mutations and weakened populations.
* Impact on wild populations:
In some cases, selectively bred animals may escape into the wild, potentially disrupting the genetic makeup of native populations.
Example:
* Domesticated animals: When farmers select cows with high milk yields to breed, the resulting herd may have a significantly reduced genetic diversity compared to wild cattle populations, making them more susceptible to diseases
6. Here are some examples of successful selective breeding programs:
* Dogs
Selective breeding of wolves for companionable traits led to the creation of a wide range of dog breeds, from the Great Dane to the Chihuahua.
* Corn
Selective breeding of teosinte plants with more kernels in Mesoamerica led to the creation of corn, which is now one of the world's most widely distributed food crops.
* Cruciferous vegetables
Selective breeding of wild mustard plants for specific traits led to the creation of broccoli, cauliflower, cabbage, kale, and kohlrabi.
* Alfalfa
Selective breeding of alfalfa to produce hairy leaves that deter the spotted alfalfa aphid.
* Dairy cattle
Selective breeding of dairy cattle has led to an increase in milk yield.
* Broilers
Selective breeding of broilers has led to reduced fatness and mortality.